Launching a print-on-demand T-shirt business on Etsy involves numerous decisions, such as which niche to pick, which colors sell best, and perhaps most crucially, choosing the right T-shirt for your store.
Let's explore four popular T-shirt models—Bella + Canvas 3001, Gildan 64000, Gildan 5000, and Comfort Colors 1717—and highlight which model is best suited for different types of Etsy stores to help you make an informed decision.
If you're new to print on demand, and are looking for the best mockups to display your t-shirt designs, try out our FREE MOCKUPS. They include all the T-shirts mentioned in this blog, and a few more becuse we care for new people starting their journey.
Let's see the t-shirt contenders:
Bella Canvas 3001
Color: Ash
The Bella Canvas 3001 is celebrated for its superior softness, contemporary fit, and eco-friendly manufacturing processes. This model is ideal for sellers who aim to position their Etsy store as a provider of high-quality, fashionable apparel. It's particularly suited for stores focusing on niche markets that value ethical production practices and are willing to pay a premium for comfort and style. The extensive color range also allows for vibrant, versatile designs, making it a top choice for fashion-forward brands.
Gildan 64000
Color: Heather Military Green
The Gildan 64000 offers a great balance between quality and affordability. It's not as soft as the Bella Canvas 3001, but it provides a respectable quality that's suitable for a wide audience. This model is perfect for Etsy sellers who need a reliable, well-priced shirt that meets customer expectations without breaking the bank. It works well for general stores that cater to a broad audience, including those launching their first line of branded merchandise.
Gildan 5000
Color: Navy
Best for Volume Sales and Promotional Items For Etsy sellers focused on maximizing profits through volume sales, the Gildan 5000 is a standout choice. This shirt is the most economical among the four, offering robustness and a classic fit at a lower price point. It's ideal for promotional items, event giveaways, or any store where price sensitivity is a significant factor for the target audience. The Gildan 5000's durability and affordability make it especially suitable for shops selling to customers who prioritize cost over premium fabric qualities.
Comfort Colors 1717
Color: Chambray
Best for Niche Boutique Stores If your Etsy store targets a niche market that loves unique, artisan-style products, the Comfort Colors 1717 is the go-to option. Known for its softness and vintage look, this T-shirt is perfect for brands that want to offer something distinct from the typical mass-produced merchandise. The garment-dyed colors provide a unique aesthetic that appeals to buyers looking for authenticity and quality. It's an excellent choice for boutique stores specializing in custom, handcrafted designs.
Tailoring Your Choice to Your Business Model:
For Premium Branding:
If your business model is built around premium products with a unique brand story, opt for the Bella Canvas 3001. The quality and ethical production align well with conscious consumerism and can justify higher price points.
Source: Printful
For Broad Appeal:
The Gildan 64000 works well for stores that cater to diverse demographics. It’s a solid choice for ensuring customer satisfaction across a range of consumers without requiring a significant investment per unit.
Source: Printful
For Profit Maximization:
Sellers focusing on maximizing profitability, especially those just starting out or operating on thin margins, will find the Gildan 5000 to be an effective option. It offers a satisfactory quality level that won't deter budget-conscious shoppers.
Source: Printful
For Unique Offerings:
The Comfort Colors 1717 allows you to carve out a niche in the market, appealing to customers who seek out special, high-quality items. It’s particularly suitable for stores that market their products as premium or boutique.
Source: Printful
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right T-shirt model for your Etsy store involves understanding not just the cost and quality of the product, but also how well it aligns with your brand identity and customer expectations. By selecting a model that complements your store’s focus—whether it’s cost efficiency, premium quality, broad appeal, or niche marketing—you can enhance your brand’s appeal and see greater success in your sales. Tailor your product offerings to reflect your target market’s preferences and your brand’s values, and you’ll build a loyal customer base eager to support your business.
